How to Identify and Manage Big Black Bugs That Mimic Bees

When observing insects in your garden, you may come across large black flying bugs that resemble bees at first glance.

These insects, though, often have unique characteristics that distinguish them from actual bees, making it important to recognize these differences for a better understanding of their behavior and ecological roles.

While we do enjoy and use the products recommended above, they are affiliate links where ‘What’s That Bug’ may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps to financial support this website from hosting to expert entomologists and writers who identify your bug requests and create the content you love.

One example of such an insect is the black fly, which has a robust body, arched thoracic region, large compound eyes, and short antennae, paired with large, fan-shaped wings, and colored either black or rarely orange or yellow.

Another example is the bee fly, part of the Bombyliidae family, which has a stout body, covered in yellow, black, or brown hairs, and transparent or patterned wings.

These insects also feature a long proboscis for feeding on pollen and nectar.

Some characteristics of the insects that resemble bees:

• Large compound eyes
• Short antennae
• Stout or robust bodies
• Transparent or fan-shaped wings
• Long proboscis for feeding on nectar
• Hairs covering their bodies, which vary in color

Identifying Big Black Flying Bugs That Look Like Bees

Bumblebees Vs. Carpenter Bees

Bumblebees and carpenter bees can often be confused due to their similar appearance. However, there are key differences to help distinguish the two:

• Coloration: Bumblebees have black and yellow stripes, while carpenter bees typically have a shiny, all-black body.
• Size: Carpenter bees are generally larger than bumblebees.
• Behavior: Bumblebees are social insects and live in colonies. Carpenter bees are solitary and nest in wood.

Example: A bee buzzing around flowers with black and yellow stripes is likely a bumblebee and not a carpenter bee.

Hoverflies Vs. Bee Flies

Hoverflies and bee flies are two other insects that can be mistaken for bees due to their black and yellow coloration.

• Eyes: Hoverflies have large reddish or marbled black eyes, while bee flies have a more standard set of eyes.
• Wings: Both have two clear wings, but hoverflies tend to have a distinct hovering behavior around flowers.
• Size: They are generally 5 to 15 millimeters long.
• Antennae: Hoverflies have short antennae, whereas bee flies usually have longer antennae.
• Proboscis: Bee flies have a long proboscis (tongue) for feeding on pollen and nectar.

Table: Comparing Features of Hoverflies and Bee Flies

Examples:

• A small flying insect with reddish eyes and a hovering behavior is likely a hoverfly.
• A bug with transparent wings and a long proboscis is probably a bee fly.

Behavior and Habitat

Bumblebees and Honeybees

Bumblebees and honeybees are social insects that live in colonies.

They are known for their role as pollinators, contributing to the ecosystem by helping plants reproduce.

Bumblebees and honeybees inhabit a variety of environments, often nesting in hollow trees or near the ground.

• Bumblebees are larger and fuzzier than honeybees
• Honeybees have a slender and more streamlined appearance
• Both can sting, but bumblebees can sting multiple times while honeybees can only sting once

Solitary Bees

Solitary bees differ from bumblebees and honeybees in that they do not live in large colonies.

However, they still play a crucial role in pollination.

Solitary bees can be found in various habitats, including gardens, forests, and meadows.

Some common types of solitary bees include mason bees and carpenter bees.

• Mason bees prefer to nest in small cavities in wood, plants, or soil
• Carpenter bees create tunnels in wood with their strong mandibles
• Most solitary bees do not sting, and if they do, it is less painful than other stinging insects

Wasps and Yellowjackets

Wasps and yellowjackets are not bees, but they can look similar to them.

They are also important pollinators but can be more aggressive than bees. Wasps and yellowjackets inhabit various habitats, often nesting under eaves, in trees, or underground.

• Wasps have slender bodies and narrow waists
• Yellowjackets are typically black and yellow with a smooth appearance
• Both types can sting multiple times, and their stings can be quite painful

Anatomy and Adaptations

Proboscis and Mouthparts

Big black flying bugs that look like bees might actually be black flies or certain types of bumble bees.

These insects have a proboscis, which is a long, tube-like structure used for feeding on nectar or other liquid substances.

• Black Flies: Short mouthparts with sharp mandibles for biting.
• Bumble Bees: Long proboscis for reaching deep into flowers.

Some examples of these insects are carpenter bees, ceratina, and digger bees.

Wings and Legs

All bees have two pairs of wings and six legs. However, the size and shape of these structures can differ among species.

Here’s a quick comparison of black flies and bumble bees wings and legs:

Eyes and Antennae

Eyes and antennae are crucial for sensing and navigating the environment. Big black flying bugs have large compound eyes and short antennae.

• Black Flies: Large compound eyes for better vision.
• Bumble Bees: Hairy compound eyes for better detection of flowers and their colors.

Types of Mimics and Imposters

Bee Mimics

Bee mimics are insects that resemble bees in appearance but belong to different families. Some common examples include:

• Carpenter bees: These large, black bees are often mistaken for bumble bees. Carpenter bees have a shiny, hairless abdomen, while bumble bees have a fuzzy, hairy abdomen.
• Black bee: Another bee lookalike, the black bee imitates the appearance of bumble bees but lacks the characteristic yellow stripes.

Bee-Flies and Bee Beetles

• Bee-flies (Bombyliidae): These insects resemble bees but belong to the fly family. They have large eyes and only one set of wings, while bees have smaller eyes and two sets of wings.
• Bee beetles: Despite their name, bee beetles are not bees at all. They mimic bees to ward off predators with their strikingly similar appearance.

Comparison Table

Cicada Killers and Horntails

• Cicada killers: These large, solitary wasps resemble hornets and might be mistaken for bees. They have similar markings and body shapes, but cicada killers prey on cicadas, unlike bees.
• Horntails: These are wood-boring insects that can resemble bees or wasps in appearance. Their long, pointed abdomen and distinctive markings make them easily mistaken for bee-like insects.

Conclusion

In the diverse world of insects, certain large black flying bugs can be easily mistaken for bees.

These insects, such as the black fly and bee fly, have distinct features that set them apart.

Black flies possess a robust body, large compound eyes, and short antennae, while bee flies, from the Bombyliidae family, have a stout body covered in hairs and a long proboscis for feeding.

Bumblebees and carpenter bees, though similar, can be differentiated by their coloration, size, and behavior.

Similarly, hoverflies and bee flies, despite their resemblance to bees, have unique characteristics like eye size and wing behavior.

Recognizing these differences is crucial for understanding their ecological roles and behaviors.