Banded vs Vine Sphinx Moth: Key Differences and Identification Tips

Banded sphinx moths and vine sphinx moths are fascinating creatures that play an essential role in our ecosystems. Both belonging to the Sphingidae family, these moths share some similarities but also have distinct features that set them apart.

The banded sphinx moth, scientifically called Eumorpha fasciatus, is a tropical species that is known to migrate to areas as far north as New England. Its sleek appearance features a dark brown background with light brown to beige contrasting bands, and narrow whitish lines on their wings.

On the other hand, the vine sphinx moth, often referred to as the lesser vine sphinx, exhibits a different range of physical characteristics. Despite many shared traits with other sphinx moths such as a long and pointed abdomen and the ability to feed on nectar via a long proboscis, the vine sphinx moth’s distinct appearance sets it apart from its banded counterpart in various ways.

Description of Banded and Vine Sphinx Moths

Appearance and Identification

Banded Sphinx Moth (Eumorpha fasciatus) is a tropical species, also known as the lesser vine sphinx, migrating as far north as New England1. Vine Sphinx Moth (Eumorpha vitis) is closely related to banded sphinx, with a similar size and coloration. Both belong to the Sphingidae family of moths2. The main differences are:

  • Banded Sphinx Moths are dark brown with light brown to beige contrasting bands1.
  • Vine Sphinx Moths are gray-green and have pale longitudinal strips2.

Wingspan and Patterns

Here is a comparison of banded and vine sphinx moths’ wingspans and wing patterns:

Feature Banded Sphinx Moth Vine Sphinx Moth
Wingspan Around 3-4 inches1 Similar to Banded Sphinx2
Forewings Dark brown with beige bands1 Gray-green with pale stripes2
Hindwings Dark brown with a single light band1 Similar to Banded Sphinx2

Both moth species have distinct patterns on their wings that make them easily identifiable1 2.

Examples of specific patterns:

  • Banded Sphinx Moths have narrow whitish lines in addition to the contrasting bands1.
  • Vine Sphinx Moths may have a gray-green background with light patches on the wings2.

In summary, the Banded Sphinx Moth and Vine Sphinx Moth are two similar moths within the Sphingidae family. They can be distinguished based on their coloration, wing patterns, and geographic distribution.

Habitat and Distribution

Regions in North and South America

Banded and vine sphinx moths can be found across various regions in North and South America:

  • Banded sphinx moth (Eumorpha fasciatus): Commonly found in tropical areas, it migrates as far north as New England and can be spotted in Texas, Arizona, and California.
  • Vine sphinx moth (Eumorpha vitis): It is distributed from Argentina to the southern United States, including Central America.

Both species can be found in areas where their host plants, such as grape, magnolia, and petunia, are present.

Variations by Species

Banded and vine sphinx moths have differences in their habitat preferences and host plants, as summarized below:

Banded sphinx moth (Eumorpha fasciatus):

  • Prefers tropical climates.
  • Migrant in regions like Nova Scotia and Mississippi.
  • Common host plants: grape, petunia.

Vine sphinx moth (Eumorpha vitis):

  • Widespread in wine-producing regions like Argentina.
  • Encountered in Central America.
  • Common host plants: grape, magnolia.
Banded Sphinx Moth Vine Sphinx Moth
Climate Tropical; migrant in some regions Wine-producing regions
Host Plants Grape, petunia Grape, magnolia

Life Cycle and Behavior

Feeding Habits and Nectar Preferences

Both banded and vine sphinx moths caterpillars have different feeding preferences. Banded sphinx moth caterpillars are known to feed on plants in the Cissus genus, while vine sphinx moth caterpillars typically feed on plants like squash, morning glory, and evening primrose.

Adult moths of both species are often seen hovering in front of flowers, drinking nectar using their long proboscis, making them similar in appearance to hummingbirds. They are also nocturnal and attracted to various night-blooming flowers like moonflowers, four-o-clocks, and morning glories.

Reproduction and Development

The life cycles of both banded and vine sphinx moths consist of four stages:

  • Egg
  • Larva (caterpillar)
  • Pupa
  • Adult

Banded Sphinx Moth:

  • Originates from tropics
  • Strays in range limit, sometimes found as far north as New England
  • Adults have dark brown background with light brown to beige contrasting bands on the wings source

Vine Sphinx Moth:

  • More commonly known as lesser vine sphinx
  • Adults have brown wings with broad, pale bands source

Adult banded and vine sphinx moths emerge from their pupal case in late winter or spring, mate, and lay their eggs source. The caterpillars undergo a series of molts, growing increasingly larger until they pupate.

Wing features:

  • Banded Sphinx Moth:

    • Forewing: two broad, pale bands
    • Hindwing: not specified
  • Vine Sphinx Moth:

    • Forewing: broad tan band from base to tip, crossed by a series of white lines
    • Hindwing: shorter, not specified

In conclusion, both banded and vine sphinx moths share similarities in their nectar preferences and life cycles, with key differences in their feeding habits and wing markings. Being nocturnal and attracted to night-blooming flowers, these fascinating creatures play an essential role in the ecosystem.

Host Plants and Interactions

Preferred Host Plants

Banded sphinx moth (Eumorpha fasciatus) and vine sphinx moth (Eumorpha vitis) are two species of hawk moths. Their larvae, known as caterpillars, prefer different host plants to feed on.

Banded Sphinx Moth:

  • Grape (Vitis species)
  • Virginia creeper (Parthenocissus species)

Vine Sphinx Moth:

  • Grape (Vitis species)
  • Cissus species
  • Images for vine sphinx host plants found here.

Other host plants they may feed on are fuchsia, petunias, moonflowers, four-o-clocks, and squash.

Effects on Agriculture and Ecosystems

Agriculture:

Banded and vine sphinx moth caterpillars can damage agricultural crops like grapes.

  • Pros: They help in controlling some weed species, such as Virginia creeper.
  • Cons: They consume foliage and sometimes fruit, damaging the plants.

Ecosystems:

Both moth species play a significant role in pollination.

  • White-lined sphinx moth and Pandora sphinx moth are well-known pollinators.
  • Adult moths feed on flower nectar, contributing to plant reproduction.

These moths are also an important food source for other organisms, such as birds and bats. As a part of the ecosystem, they help maintain balance among insect and plant populations.

Identification and Resources

How to Identify the Moths

Banded Sphinx moth (Eumorpha fasciatus) and Lesser Vine Sphinx moth are both part of the sphinx moths family. To identify them, look at the following features:

  • Adults:

    • Banded Sphinx moth: dark brown background, light brown to beige bands, and narrow whitish lines on the wings1.
    • Lesser Vine Sphinx moth: upperside dark pinkish-brown, sharp pinkish-white bands, and streaks on the wings2.
  • Caterpillars:

    • Banded Sphinx moth: costa with pinkish-white bands, pink patch on the inner margin3.
    • Lesser Vine Sphinx moth: costa with pinkish-white bands, outer margin with pink patch4.

A great source for moth identification, including photos from amateurs and naturalists, is the Moth Photographers Group. Remember to confirm your findings with expert professional advice.

Sources for Reliable and Accurate Information

To support your moth identification journey, consider visiting the following resources:

  1. Extension Office: Check your local extension office as they may offer resources and assistance in identifying sphinx moths5.
  2. BugGuide: This clickable guide is an invaluable resource for amateurs and naturalists alike, aiming to understand the diverse natural world6.

Remember, accurate information is crucial when identifying moths, so always consult with experts and use reliable sources to ensure correct identifications.

Footnotes

  1. Banded Sphinx Moth – NCSU 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

  2. Grapevine Sphinx Moth – BugGuide 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

  3. https://naes.agnt.unr.edu/PMS/Pubs/1434_2020_01.pdf

  4. https://naes.agnt.unr.edu/PMS/Pubs/1434_2020_01.pdf

  5. https://extension.oregonstate.edu/pests-weeds-diseases/insects/insect-identification

  6. https://extension.oregonstate.edu/pests-weeds-diseases/insects/insect-identification

Reader Emails

Over the years, our website, whatsthatbug.com has received hundreds of letters and some interesting images asking us about these insects. Scroll down to have a look at some of them.

Letter 1 – Vine Sphinx? or Banded Sphinx? Could go either way.

 

my backyard moth
I got the following information when I had sent in my moth photo taken in my backyard just north of Boston, MA. Using the information I got I stumbled on your site and LOVE it. Thought you might be interested and just MAYBE get you to guess. However, I can’t get the moth to show me its hindwings.
“It’s too bad I don’t know where your backyard is. Read on… It is either the banded sphinx, Eumorpha fasciata, or the vine sphinx, Eumorpha vitis. The way to distinguish them is to examine some very small features of the hindwings, which you photo does not show. Vine sphinx is found all over eastern North America, while the banded sphinx would be very rare in the northern half of North America. That’s why I was wondering where your backyard is–it might almost rule out the banded sphinx, even without seeing the hindwings. John Snyder
Dept. of Biology
Furman University
Greenville, SC USA”
Sorry, but the photo was not attached, Anne [in Massachusetts]

HI Anne,
As rank amateurs, we are hardly in a position to disagree with experts at a University. That said, we checked the USGS report listed on Bill Oehlke’s excellent website and have come to an agreement with Professor Snyder that the Vine Sphinx is more likely because it is not listed as common in Massachusetts, only as a confirmed sighting. However, according to the illustration in our very old Holland Guide, the wing pattern visible on the upper wings does seem a closer match to the Banded Sphinx. We could go either way given that the moth is confirmed in Massachusetts. Though we don’t want to disagree with Professor Snyder, if you had sent this in without his comments, we would have probably identified it as a Banded Sphinx.

Reader Emails

Over the years, our website, whatsthatbug.com has received hundreds of letters and some interesting images asking us about these insects. Scroll down to have a look at some of them.

Letter 1 – Vine Sphinx? or Banded Sphinx? Could go either way.

 

my backyard moth
I got the following information when I had sent in my moth photo taken in my backyard just north of Boston, MA. Using the information I got I stumbled on your site and LOVE it. Thought you might be interested and just MAYBE get you to guess. However, I can’t get the moth to show me its hindwings.
“It’s too bad I don’t know where your backyard is. Read on… It is either the banded sphinx, Eumorpha fasciata, or the vine sphinx, Eumorpha vitis. The way to distinguish them is to examine some very small features of the hindwings, which you photo does not show. Vine sphinx is found all over eastern North America, while the banded sphinx would be very rare in the northern half of North America. That’s why I was wondering where your backyard is–it might almost rule out the banded sphinx, even without seeing the hindwings. John Snyder
Dept. of Biology
Furman University
Greenville, SC USA”
Sorry, but the photo was not attached, Anne [in Massachusetts]

HI Anne,
As rank amateurs, we are hardly in a position to disagree with experts at a University. That said, we checked the USGS report listed on Bill Oehlke’s excellent website and have come to an agreement with Professor Snyder that the Vine Sphinx is more likely because it is not listed as common in Massachusetts, only as a confirmed sighting. However, according to the illustration in our very old Holland Guide, the wing pattern visible on the upper wings does seem a closer match to the Banded Sphinx. We could go either way given that the moth is confirmed in Massachusetts. Though we don’t want to disagree with Professor Snyder, if you had sent this in without his comments, we would have probably identified it as a Banded Sphinx.

Reader Emails

Over the years, our website, whatsthatbug.com has received hundreds of letters and some interesting images asking us about these insects. Scroll down to have a look at some of them.

Reader Emails

Over the years, our website, whatsthatbug.com has received hundreds of letters and some interesting images asking us about these insects. Scroll down to have a look at some of them.

Reader Emails

Over the years, our website, whatsthatbug.com has received hundreds of letters and some interesting images asking us about these insects. Scroll down to have a look at some of them.

Reader Emails

Over the years, our website, whatsthatbug.com has received hundreds of letters and some interesting images asking us about these insects. Scroll down to have a look at some of them.

Authors

    by
  • Bugman

    Bugman aka Daniel Marlos has been identifying bugs since 1999. whatsthatbug.com is his passion project and it has helped millions of readers identify the bug that has been bugging them for over two decades. You can reach out to him through our Contact Page.

  • Piyushi Dhir

    Piyushi is a nature lover, blogger and traveler at heart. She lives in beautiful Canada with her family. Piyushi is an animal lover and loves to write about all creatures.

Leave a Comment